How to gather digital evidence for court in an online counterfeit case

Legal issues07/13/2026
How to gather digital evidence for court in an online counterfeit case

Why it is important to collect evidence immediately

Unlike traditional commerce, the digital environment is constantly changing. An infringer can delete a product listing, change the description, replace photos, or completely close a "store" within minutes of receiving a complaint. If evidence was not saved in time, proving the fact of infringement becomes significantly more difficult.

The sooner the right holder records the violation, the higher the likelihood of successfully removing counterfeit goods, filing a claim against the seller, and recovering compensation through court, as well as establishing a connection between multiple infringers.

What evidence do courts accept

Several types of evidence are typically used simultaneously in trademark protection and anti-counterfeiting disputes.

1. Screenshots of pages showing the infringement

This is the most common method of documenting an infringement. It is important to preserve the full URL of the page, as well as the date and time when the evidence was captured.

When a suspicious product listing is identified, it is advisable to record as much information as possible by taking screenshots of:

1. The product name and SKU;

2. The brand under which the product is marketed;

3. The product’s visual content (images);

4. The product description and specifications;

5. The product price;

6. Seller information;

7. Customer reviews, particularly those indicating discrepancies in product quality, packaging, or other characteristics.

In practice, incomplete documentation of an infringement is one of the main challenges when preparing cease-and-desist letters and filing lawsuits. Therefore, the more information a screenshot captures, the greater its evidentiary value.

2. Archived copies of web pages

In addition to screenshots, it is useful to save complete copies of web pages. This method helps establish the content of a product listing and preserve details that may not be visible in a screenshot, even if the listing is subsequently deleted or modified.

3. Correspondence with the seller

If the rights holder has contacted the seller directly, it is essential to preserve messages, emails, responses to cease-and-desist letters, and notifications from online marketplaces. Such correspondence may help establish that the infringer was aware of the unauthorized use of the brand.

4. Trademark registration and ownership documents

The foundation of any trademark dispute is documentary evidence confirming the rights to the brand. Depending on the circumstances, this may include:

- A trademark registration certificate issued under a national or international registration;

- An agreement assigning the exclusive right to the trademark;

- A license agreement granting the licensee rights under an exclusive license;

- A non-exclusive license agreement accompanied by a power of attorney from the rights holder authorizing the licensee to exercise the relevant powers.

Without evidence confirming the rights to the brand (trademark), it is impossible to bring a claim for its protection and, consequently, to establish that an infringement has occurred.

How to take a screenshot correctly so that it withstands an opponent's objections

Screenshots are easy to challenge: they can be edited, do not show the exact source of the image, and the file creation date alone provides little evidentiary value. Therefore, the rights holder’s goal should be to make the screenshot appear as a document whose authenticity cannot reasonably be called into question.

To achieve this, several rules should be followed:

1. Ensure that the browser’s address bar displays the full URL. Without it, it is difficult for the court and the opposing party to determine exactly where the information was published.

2. Make sure the system date and time are visible. To do this, capture the entire screen rather than a selected area, ensuring that the taskbar or status bar is included in the screenshot.

3. Capture the entire page, not just a fragment. Record the top of the page (product name, images, and price), as well as the specifications, seller information, and customer reviews. If the page is long, take a series of consecutive screenshots or record the screen while scrolling through the page.

4. Preserve a sequence of screenshots rather than a single image. A series showing the transition from the search results page to the product listing documents the user’s navigation path and reduces the risk of objections that the page was specially prepared for evidentiary purposes.

5. Check that no browser extensions or settings are altering the appearance of the page. These may include ad blockers, automatic translation tools, and custom themes. Also, check whether you are logged into a personal account, as the listing may appear differently to different users.

6. Save the original files immediately and leave them unchanged. Do not crop or edit them. If a screenshot needs to be prepared as an exhibit to a statement of claim—for example, by highlighting the trademark with a frame—retain both the original and the edited copy.

7. Maintain an evidence log. Record who captured the screenshots, when they were taken, which device was used, and the sequence in which they were captured. This document may prove useful if the opposing party challenges the authenticity of the evidence.

Ordinary screenshots are well suited for cease-and-desist letters and complaints to online marketplaces. However, in more serious disputes, they should be supplemented with archived copies of web pages, test purchases, or a notarial inspection. The higher the expected compensation, the more attention should be paid to the reliability of each piece of evidence.

How to identify the offender

Even a perfectly documented infringement may fail to produce the desired result if the rights holder does not know whom to pursue. In the online environment, infringers often conceal their identities behind store names, usernames, or multiple accounts, meaning that information about them must be collected from various sources.

What information should be sought and preserved?

1. Seller information in the product listing. On online marketplaces, sellers typically provide the name of the company or the full name of an individual entrepreneur, as well as their Taxpayer Identification Number (INN), Primary State Registration Number (OGRN), or Primary State Registration Number for Individual Entrepreneurs (OGRNIP). This information should be saved in a screenshot together with the product listing, as the seller may subsequently change these details or close the account.

2. Information on independent websites. Relevant details may be found in the “About Us,” “Contacts,” “Public Offer,” and “Shipping and Payment Terms” sections, as well as in domain registration and hosting records. The seller’s details can be verified against publicly accessible state registers, including the Unified State Register of Legal Entities (EGRUL) and the Unified State Register of Individual Entrepreneurs (EGRIP).

3. Test purchase records. Receipts, delivery notes, shipping documents, and sender information often contain the actual seller’s details, which may differ from those provided in the product listing.

4. Requests to online platforms. If the available information is insufficient, the rights holder may contact the marketplace or hosting provider to request disclosure of information about the seller or resource owner. The procedure and scope of such disclosure depend on the platform’s policies and applicable law, so it is advisable to clarify in advance what information can be obtained.

5. Connections between accounts. If an infringer operates multiple stores, they can be compared based on common characteristics, such as identical product images and descriptions, matching registration details and contact information, the same shipping addresses, or similar product ranges. This can help establish that multiple listings are operated by the same person and ensure that the full scope of the infringement is taken into account when calculating the claims.

Identifying the infringer also affects the subsequent enforcement strategy. Whether the defendant is a legal entity, an individual entrepreneur, a self-employed individual, or a private individual determines the rules of jurisdiction, the applicable pre-litigation dispute resolution procedure, and the prospects of recovering compensation.

Therefore, the infringer’s identity should be established in parallel with evidence collection, rather than only after it has been completed.

When a test purchase is necessary

In some cases, it is not enough to prove the use of a trademark on a product page. It is necessary to confirm that counterfeit products are actually being delivered to the customer. For this purpose, a test purchase is conducted.

After receiving the goods, it is recommended to keep:

• the cash receipt;

• the packaging;

• shipping documents;

• photographs of the product;

• an unboxing video;

• product labeling.

A test purchase allows for obtaining the most convincing evidence of an infringement and often becomes a key argument in a legal dispute.

What to do after fixation: next steps

The evidence collected does not, by itself, resolve the issue. It serves as the basis for subsequent action. A typical enforcement process involves the following steps.

Review of rights and assessment of evidence. Ensure that the trademark registration is valid, covers the relevant classes of goods, and that the infringement has been sufficiently documented. At this stage, it becomes clear whether the available evidence is sufficient or whether additional evidence is needed, such as a test purchase.

Filing a complaint with the platform. If the infringement occurs on an online marketplace or social media platform, the quickest way to stop it is often to submit a complaint through the platform’s dedicated intellectual property protection procedures. The complaint should include trademark registration documents and evidence documenting the infringement. This does not replace a formal cease-and-desist letter, but it often enables the infringing product listing to be removed quickly.

Sending a cease-and-desist letter to the infringer. The letter notifies the infringer of the violation and sets out the rights holder’s demands, such as ceasing trademark use, removing the product from sale, and paying compensation. It also establishes that the infringer was notified of the violation and had an opportunity to remedy it voluntarily. In disputes between companies and individual entrepreneurs before commercial (arbitrazh) courts, pre-litigation procedures are generally mandatory: the claimant must send a formal demand and wait until the applicable statutory period expires.

Interim and precautionary measures. If there is a risk that the infringer may conceal or destroy the goods or evidence, the rights holder may consider applying for interim relief or preliminary measures to secure the claim. Such measures are not available or appropriate in every case, so the decision should be based on the specific circumstances of the dispute.

Filing a lawsuit and calculating compensation. If the infringer fails to respond or refuses to comply with the demands, the rights holder may bring a claim before the court. The claims may include an injunction against further infringement, seizure of counterfeit goods, and recovery of compensation. The completeness of the evidence collected also affects how effectively the amount of compensation can be substantiated.

Monitoring for repeat infringements. The removal of a product listing does not necessarily mean that the infringement has ceased. Infringers often open new stores or change their names. Therefore, monitoring should continue after the dispute has been resolved, and records of previous infringements should be retained. Repeated infringement by the same party may be taken into account when determining the amount of compensation.

Consistency is essential at every stage. When the platform complaint, cease-and-desist letter, and court claim are all based on the same body of evidence, the rights holder’s position is more coherent, and the entire enforcement process can proceed more efficiently.

Is a notarial inspection of the website necessary

Notarial preservation of evidence is used in cases where there is a risk of information being quickly deleted. A notary records the content of a page as of a specific date and prepares an official inspection report of the online resource. Such a document carries significant evidentiary weight and helps reduce the likelihood of disputes regarding the authenticity of the submitted materials.

Notarial inspection is most commonly used in major legal disputes, large-scale violations, cases involving significant potential compensation, and for documenting violations on independent websites and social media platforms.

Typical mistakes of rightsholders

Even when a violation exists, companies often lose the ability to effectively protect their rights due to mistakes at the evidence collection stage.

The most common ones are:

1. Relying on a single screenshot

2. Absence of a test purchase

3. Delayed documentation – the product listing may disappear before the claims process begins.

4. Lack of systematic monitoring

How automation helps collect evidence

Modern brands are increasingly using automated monitoring of marketplaces and other online platforms.

Such systems allow for the prompt identification of new violations, preservation of product listing history, recording of changes in descriptions, collection of seller data, and tracking of repeat violations.

Automation significantly reduces the time between the detection of counterfeit goods and the start of legal action, while also helping to build a structured evidence base for claims and litigation.

Conclusion

In counterfeiting cases, it is not only the discovery of the infringement itself that is crucial, but also the quality of the evidence collected. Screenshots, archived web pages, test purchases, correspondence with sellers, and trademark documentation make it possible to build a strong position for brand protection. The faster the right holder records the infringement and the more comprehensive the evidence base, the higher the chances of successfully removing counterfeit products and holding the infringer liable, including recovering compensation for the unauthorized use of the trademark.

FAQ

Are regular screenshots sufficient for court?

Screenshots can be used as evidence; however, in most cases, it is recommended to supplement them with other materials: archived page copies, test purchases, correspondence with the seller, and a notarized inspection of the website. A comprehensive set of evidence significantly increases the chances of a successful outcome.

Is a test purchase necessary for every violation?

Not always. If the violation relates solely to the unauthorized use of a trademark in a product listing, a test purchase may be unnecessary. However, if counterfeit sales are suspected, purchasing the item often becomes the most compelling evidence.

What should be done if the seller deletes the product listing after a complaint?

This is why it is crucial to document the violation immediately upon discovery. If screenshots, page copies, and other digital evidence have been preserved, the deletion of the listing does not prevent the right holder from filing a claim or taking legal action.

Recent articles

Counterfeit Goods: What They Are and How Businesses Can Combat Them
Legal issues11/13/2026

Counterfeit Goods: What They Are and How Businesses Can Combat Them

Read
How to integrate brand monitoring into the right holder's workflow
Search for counterfeits11/05/2026

How to integrate brand monitoring into the right holder's workflow

Read

Get in touch

Tell us about your task — we will reply during business hours within one business day.

Submit a request

I agree to the processing of personal data in accordance with the Privacy Policy